Skip to content Skip to footer

Human rights defenders / Protection Pathways Toolkit / Tool 2

Tool 2

Choosing the channel

Closed Space Engagement Avenues Scorecard

Before you choose the body, score the channel: is it safe for you, and has the person concerned agreed?

If you are in danger now → First 24 Hours CardsWe do not save or send anything you choose or type. Why?

How to use this tool

The quick path (20 minutes)

  • Name your goal in one sentence (Section 2).
  • Use the goal table to list two or three realistic channels.
  • Score each channel on the worksheet (Annex A), starting with the two gate questions: Risk and Consent.
  • Choose the channel with the best impact at a risk the people affected accept. If no channel meets that test, go to Section 7.

Your top three exposures: if you have used Tool 1, bring them and the Country Pattern Sheet for your country. If not, answer three questions now: (1) Who could act against you or the people involved, and what can they actually do? (2) What can they reach: your public profile, routines, devices, relatives, documents? (3) Which harm would be most serious, even if it seems unlikely? Your answers are your top three exposures. Keep them in your head, or in code.
Take to Tool 3: the channel you chose, so you can write for that audience.

Keep the scorecard safe. A completed scorecard shows your plans, contacts and judgements about risk. Use codes, keep detail to a minimum, and do not carry a completed copy across a border.

Meet Nour, a woman defender from one of the focus countries. She has mapped the risks she faces. She has now documented the detention of a local lawyer and wants it to stop. She is known locally and fears a summons and pressure on her family. This tool follows her decision. All examples are fictional.

1. Advocacy or protection? Decide what you need first

You need

Examples

Use

An advocacy route: to influence, inform, hold to account or draw attention

UN mechanism, embassy, EU, court, media, coalition

This tool

A protection measure: to be safer now

Lawyer, digital responder, safe accommodation, psychosocial care, grant, relocation

First 24 Hours Cards, or a protection organisation

Both

Protection is needed before or alongside advocacy

Secure protection first. Then use this tool. Re-assess after each step

Never use an advocacy score to decide whether someone needs urgent protection.

2. Start with your goal

Be precise about what you want to happen. A different goal points to a different channel.

If your goal is to…

Channels that usually fit best

Watch out for

Stop an imminent harm (arrest, disappearance, transfer, deportation)

Protection organisations’ emergency lines; UN Special Procedures urgent appeal; Working Group on Enforced Disappearances urgent action (disappearances reported within three months); embassies of states the authorities listen to

Speed matters most. Use contacts you built in advance. The UN will usually share the victim’s name with the government

Free a detained person

Working Group on Arbitrary Detention; Special Procedures; private diplomatic action; trial observation by embassies; publicity before sentencing, if consent and risk allow (Tool 1, Section 9)

A study of political prisoners in China found that international attention before sentencing made release before sentencing more likely. Treat it as a signal, not a rule. Opinions of the Working Group name the person

Protect a person, not urgently

Special Procedures submission; private embassy contact; OHCHR’s reprisals team if the threat is linked to cooperation with the UN

A non-public route can still disclose the name to the government. Special Procedures communications are published later

Respond to a reprisal for UN cooperation

OHCHR reprisals team (ohchr-reprisals@un.org); the UN body you engaged with; the UN Secretary-General’s annual report

Consent is required. Cases can appear anonymously

Hold perpetrators to account

Documentation for the record; treaty-body complaints where available; for Syria, the IIIM, universal-jurisdiction prosecutors in Europe, and the missing-persons institution; EU human rights sanctions dossiers

Slow, and it needs a victim who consents to the exposure. Evidence standards are high

Change a law or policy

UPR and treaty-body shadow reports; coalitions; European Parliament; diplomats; national institutions where they are independent

Pattern reporting can still identify people in small groups

Raise visibility

Media; public reports; Human Rights Council statements and side events; campaigns

High exposure that cannot be undone. Needs consent for each audience and a plan for harassment

Any goal, when acting directly is unsafe

Intermediaries, coalitions, lower-attribution submissions (Tool 4)

The intermediary also holds sensitive information

3. The avenues: what each can realistically deliver

The Annex has a reference card for most avenues below; the Arab Human Rights Committee, domestic courts and parliamentarians have none. Each card lists purpose, who can use it, who learns identities, what becomes public and limits.

3.1 United Nations

  • Special Procedures (Special Rapporteurs, Working Groups)
    • Who can use it: anyone. No treaty ratification is needed.
    • What they do: experts can send a communication to the government. The communication and any reply are published about 60 days later.
    • Identity: the UN does not disclose the submitter’s identity, but the details of the case can still point to the source. The victim’s name usually goes to the government unless the experts withhold it for safety.
  • Working Group on Arbitrary Detention issues opinions on whether a detention is arbitrary.
  • Working Group on Enforced Disappearances has an urgent action procedure for disappearances reported within three months, and a standard procedure for older cases.
  • OHCHR reprisals team
    • For: intimidation and reprisals for cooperating with the UN.
    • Route: ohchr-reprisals@un.org, open all year.
    • Consent: required.
  • Universal Periodic Review (UPR)
    • What it is: a public review of each state about every five years.
    • What is public: stakeholder submissions and the names of submitting organisations.
  • Treaty bodies
    • Shadow reports: for the review of a state.
    • Individual complaints: only if the state has accepted the procedure. Check this first.
  • Human Rights Council
    • What it offers: oral and written statements and side events.
    • Access: you need an organisation with UN consultative status. Visibility, and exposure, are high.

3.2 Regional

  • African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights (for Egypt).
    • What it offers: individual communications, a Special Rapporteur on Human Rights Defenders, and a focal point on reprisals.
    • Limits: decisions are slow and often not implemented.
  • Arab Human Rights Committee.
    • What it does: reviews reports of states that have ratified the Arab Charter. Check whether your state has ratified it.
    • Limits: no individual complaints. Its value is limited to shadow reports.

3.3 European and diplomatic

  • Embassies of states the authorities listen to:
    • private démarches;
    • trial observation;
    • prison visit requests;
    • emergency visas.
  • EU missions have human rights defender liaison officers under the EU Guidelines on Human Rights Defenders.
  • European Parliament: urgency resolutions, questions to the Commission, letters from members.
  • ProtectDefenders.eu: emergency grants, temporary relocation (by referral) and other support.
  • EU Global Human Rights Sanctions Regime:
    • How it works: member states propose listings, and civil society can supply evidence dossiers.
    • Limits: the process is slow, political and confidential.

3.4 Accountability and justice (especially Syria)

  • IIIM (International, Impartial and Independent Mechanism for Syria): collects and preserves evidence of international crimes for future prosecutions. It works with civil society under a cooperation protocol.
  • Independent Institution on Missing Persons in Syria (IIMP): clarifies the fate of missing people and supports their families.
  • Universal jurisdiction: war-crimes units in some European countries investigate crimes committed in Syria. Germany and France have already tried cases.
  • Syrian national commissions on transitional justice and on missing persons were created by decree on 17 May 2025. Their independence and effectiveness are still unclear.

3.5 National

  • National human rights institutions: independence varies widely. Check each one before you share anything.
  • Domestic courts: may be available, but complaints can expose you.
  • Parliamentarians: sometimes a channel, especially in Lebanon and Iraq.

3.6 Host country (for defenders in exile)

  • Police and prosecutors, for threats or surveillance in the host country.
  • Members of parliament and parliamentary committees.
  • Asylum and immigration authorities, where transnational repression affects your status.
  • Ask a support organisation first whether the host authorities can be trusted. Some host states have deported dissidents or handed them over.

3.7 Media, platforms and the public

  • International and regional media.
  • Platform reporting routes and trusted-partner programmes for coordinated attacks.
  • Public campaigns.

Exposure from these channels is high and cannot be undone.

3.8 Intermediaries and coalitions

A vetted organisation can submit in its own name and hold sensitive details. This reduces direct attribution. It does not guarantee anonymity (Tool 4).

4. The 2026–2027 reality check: a UN under strain

The UN’s financial crisis has reduced what UN mechanisms can deliver. Plan with these figures in mind:

  • Treaty bodies: sessions fell from 145 in 2024 to 103 in 2025. Dozens of state reviews have been postponed. The Committee against Torture cancelled a session for the first time.
  • Special Procedures: mandated country visits have been halved, from two a year to one. One-third or more of Working Group sessions have been cut, including those of the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention. The Working Group on Enforced Disappearances carries a backlog of about 8,000 cases.
  • Human Rights Council: sessions are shorter. General-debate speaking time is 1 minute 30 seconds.
  • OHCHR field presence: closed or significantly reduced in 17 countries.

What this means for your choice:

  • UN routes that do not wait for a session or a review: Special Procedures communications, urgent appeals and the reprisals channel. They are less exposed to postponements, but they are not immune to the cuts.
  • Treaty-body timing is uncertain. Check the live calendar before you plan around a review.
  • Written submissions and joint statements carry more than a 90-second speech.
  • Combine routes. UN routes do more alongside diplomatic, European and regional routes than on their own.

5. Score your options

Score each realistic channel on eight criteria. Use the worksheet in the Annex.

Try it

The two gates first

Every channel first passes two gates: Risk and Consent. Score each one, and see whether the channel passes or is turned back.

#

Criterion

The question

1

Access

Is this channel actually open to us? Can it reach the people who can change the situation?

2

Risk: GATE

What physical, legal, digital and reprisal risk does it create for everyone involved? Use your top three exposures, from Tool 1 or from the three questions at the start of this tool.

3

Consent: GATE

Do the people affected freely and knowingly agree to this level of exposure, for each audience?

4

Impact

Will it move the people who can change the situation?

5

Speed

Is it fast enough for how urgent this is?

6

Reversibility

Can we pause or step back, or is this a one-way step?

7

Disclosure

Who will learn an identity: the receiving body, the government, partners, the public?

8

Cost

Do we have the time, money, skills and relationships it needs?

Mark each criterion with one word

  • GO: this criterion is met.
  • FIX: it can be met if we change something. Write down what needs to change.
  • STOP: it cannot be met.
  • CHECK: we do not know yet. Write down what we need to find out.

Read the result

  • Gates first. If Risk or Consent is STOP, do not use this channel. If either is FIX, make the change and score the channel again. If either is CHECK, wait: do not use the channel until the check is done.
  • Then the rest. Two or more STOPs on the other six criteria mean the channel is a poor fit. If a FIX on one of these criteria cannot be changed, record it as an accepted residual risk in the decision.
  • Choose the channel with the best impact whose gates are both GO. Record why you chose it, what was changed to get there, who owns each change, and when you will review the decision.
  • Score again when something changes: a new threat, a new stage in the case, a new deadline.

Whose risk? Score risk for everyone who carries consequences, not only for the person speaking. That includes sources, relatives, the intermediary and co-defendants. A closed briefing may reduce public visibility but disclose names to the government. Women and LGBTQI+ defenders may face sexualised smears, outing and family pressure. Score those risks with the person’s own assessment.

6. Worked examples

Example 1: Nour, a detained lawyer

Goal: end the arbitrary detention of a local lawyer. The lawyer’s family has asked Nour to help.

Channel

Access

Risk (gate)

Consent (gate)

Impact

Speed

Revers.

Disclosure

Cost

Result

Local media, in Nour’s name

GO

STOP

FIX

FIX

GO

STOP

STOP

GO

Not used. Risk gate failed

Special Procedures, submitted by Nour directly

GO

FIX

CHECK

GO

GO

GO

FIX

GO

Not used as scored. Changed and scored again as the next option

Special Procedures and Working Group on Arbitrary Detention, submitted by a vetted coalition, with private embassy contact in parallel

GO

GO

GO

GO

FIX

GO

FIX

GO

Chosen


What Nour changed to reach GO:

  • Risk: a vetted coalition submits in its own name, so Nour is not the submitter. She removed details that only she could know.
  • Consent: the lawyer’s family agreed that the name may go to the UN and to the government. They accepted that it will become public: the Special Procedures communication is published about 60 days after it is sent, and the Working Group’s opinion is published with the lawyer’s name. They did not agree to media publicity. The lawyer had agreed before arrest to UN action if detained. Both decisions are recorded.
  • Speed: stays FIX, accepted. The urgent appeal is fast; the Working Group’s opinion takes months.
  • Disclosure: stays FIX, accepted. The government will learn the lawyer’s name. This is accepted because the lawyer is already detained and named in the case file. It is reviewed if the family’s position changes.
  • Review: 30 days, at the lawyer’s next court date, or before the communication is published, whichever comes first. Media publicity is reconsidered before sentencing (Tool 1, Section 9).

Example 2: Karim, in exile, after his brother was summoned

Goal: stop pressure on Karim’s family at home. The summons came two weeks after Karim briefed a UN Special Rapporteur.

Channel

Risk (gate)

Consent (gate)

Impact

Result

Public post naming the summons

STOP (brother at risk)

STOP (brother refused)

FIX

Not used

Report to OHCHR reprisals team: brother’s name shared with OHCHR only, not to be raised with the government by name or published

GO

GO (brother agreed to this use, recorded)

FIX, accepted (slow, but builds the UN record)

Chosen

Host-country police report on online threats against Karim

GO (a support organisation confirmed the host police can be trusted; Karim reports with a lawyer)

GO

GO for Karim’s own safety

Chosen

Private contact with a foreign embassy in his home country

FIX

CHECK

GO

Wait until the brother decides

Karim used two channels in parallel. He waits on a third until his brother decides.

7. When every avenue is risky

Sometimes no channel passes both gates. Pausing or not acting can be the right protection decision. Before deciding, consider these options.

  • Shift from the case to the pattern. Report a pattern across several cases, without naming anyone. Test whether the details could still identify a person in a small group.
  • Change who speaks. An intermediary, a coalition or an international organisation can carry the issue (Tool 4).
  • Change the audience. A non-public route, such as OHCHR’s reprisals team or an embassy, instead of a public campaign. A Special Procedures communication is not a public campaign, but it is published later.
  • Change the timing. Wait until the person is safe, has left the country, or a review date strengthens the case. Delay is legitimate if waiting does not endanger anyone.
  • Record now, act later. Document the case securely so it can be used when conditions change. Keep a coded record of each engagement and every measure that follows, with dates, stored apart from your identity documents. For a ready-made timeline, see Tool 1, Section 10.

8. Timing and sequencing

Plan around cycles:

  • UPR: submissions are due months before the review. Check the deadline on OHCHR’s UPR pages.
  • UN Secretary-General’s reprisals report: information is due by 15 April each year.
  • Human Rights Council sessions: March, June–July, and September–October.
  • Treaty-body reviews: check the live calendar. Postponements are frequent (Section 4).

Those same moments raise your risk. A few days ahead, not the night before: tell one trusted person your plan, timing and check-in schedule, and what they do if you miss a check-in; reduce what is on your devices; warn the relatives who could be approached. Tool 1, Section 5 has more detail.

Sequence deliberately:

  • Start with the least exposing channel that fits the goal.
  • Escalate only after checking consent and risk again.
  • Going public is a one-way step. It can open doors, but you cannot undo it.
  • One channel can expose another. A public UPR submission can reveal the source of an earlier communication. Score each channel separately before you combine them.

9. If you travel to Geneva, including with HuMENA’s mission

Score before you travel. Decide:

  • What you will raise, and in which format. Formats include:
    • a closed briefing;
    • a bilateral meeting with a state;
    • a side event;
    • a statement delivered by someone else.
  • What name, if any, you will use.
  • What photographs and social media posts are allowed.

Before you travel, get advice for your route, reduce the sensitive data you carry, and do not carry source names or a completed scorecard. Defenders have been stopped at their own airport on the way to international meetings. Tool 1, Section 5 (travel and border risk) and Tool 3 (wording) have more detail.

Limits

This tool supports a reasoned decision. It does not decide for you, it does not guarantee that a channel will work, and it is not legal advice. Mechanism rules, deadlines and capacity change. Check the live official page before you rely on any of them. Individual complaints and regional procedures need advice from a lawyer on admissibility and disclosure.

Glossary

  • Avenue / channel: a route for raising a concern, such as a UN mechanism, an embassy, a court, the media or a coalition.
  • Gate criterion: Risk or Consent. If either one fails, the channel cannot be used unchanged.
  • Special Procedures: independent UN experts (Special Rapporteurs and Working Groups) who can send communications to governments.
  • UPR (Universal Periodic Review): the public review of every UN member state, about every five years.
  • Treaty body: a UN committee that monitors a human rights treaty.
  • Shadow report: civil society input into a treaty-body review.
  • Démarche: a formal diplomatic approach to a government.
  • Universal jurisdiction: the power of a national court to try certain serious crimes committed abroad.
  • Pattern-level advocacy: reporting a pattern across cases rather than naming an individual.

Key sources

  • OHCHR. Special Procedures: Communications. https://www.ohchr.org/en/special-procedures-human-rights-council/what-are-communications
  • OHCHR. How to share information about cases of intimidation and reprisals. https://www.ohchr.org/en/reprisals/how-share-information-about-cases-intimidation-and-reprisals
  • OHCHR. UPR: contributions and participation of “other stakeholders”. https://www.ohchr.org/en/hr-bodies/upr/ngos-nhris
  • OHCHR. Individual communications procedures of the treaty bodies. https://www.ohchr.org/en/treaty-bodies/individual-communications-procedures-treaty-bodies
  • ISHR (2026). UN financial crisis: Mapping the impact for human rights. https://ishr.ch/toolbox/resources/un-financial-crisis-mapping-the-impact-for-human-rights/
  • ISHR (2025). Toolkit on assessing and mitigating risks of reprisals for UN engagement. https://ishr.ch/resources/toolkit-on-assessing-and-mitigating-risks-of-reprisals-for-un-engagement/
  • Council of the EU (2008). Ensuring Protection: European Union Guidelines on Human Rights Defenders.
  • ProtectDefenders.eu. https://protectdefenders.eu/

Related HuMENA publications

  • HuMENA. (2026). Advocacy from Exile: A Strategic Guide for Human Rights Defenders. https://humena.org/advocacy-from-exile-toolkit/
  • HuMENA. (2021). MENA Diaspora Paving Road to Justice: What Is Strategic Litigation and Why It Matters. https://humena.org/mena-diaspora-paving-road-to-justice-what-is-strategic-litigation-and-why-it-matters/